Beyond Lipstick Swatches: How Leading Beauty Brands Are Revolutionizing Influencer Marketing

If you're in beauty marketing, you've probably spent countless hours analyzing competitor content, scrutinizing influencer engagement rates, and wondering if that viral TikTok trend is right for your brand. You're not alone. The beauty industry's relationship with influencer marketing has transformed dramatically, moving far beyond the days of simple product reviews and makeup tutorials.

The beauty industry has always been at the forefront of social media marketing innovation. While this is not surprising, given that Inspiration has always been at the core of beauty marketing for decades, but as we move into 2025, the game has changed and we'll learn how identification and authenticity are now the new best friends of inspiration in influencer marketing. It's no longer just about getting your products in front of the right audiences and showcasing beauty- it's about building trust and turning those views into actual sales to get more from your brand building budgets and prove ROI.

If you're looking to understand how successful beauty brands are navigating this shift then this read if for you as we'll dive into how some of the leading beauty brands are engaging with influencers on social media, and why their strategies are working.

The Current State of Beauty Influencer Marketing

Beauty influencer marketing thrives on diverse content formats that shape trends, drive engagement, and influence purchasing decisions. From occasion-based looks and product reviews to viral aesthetics and expert techniques, creators connect with audiences through a mix of education, inspiration, and entertainment. Beauty is also deeply embedded in lifestyle narratives, with self-care and mental health playing a growing role in content, while pop culture remains a constant source of inspiration. Understanding these key content formats provides a foundation for exploring how brands strategically leverage influencer marketing to build trust and drive sales.

‍

Want to dive deeper into the social commerce strategy is headed? Check out our 2025 Social Commerce Strategy Report.

How Top Beauty Brands Are Leading the Way

But why are some brands crushing it, while others still battle to connect and convert with customers? We've analyzed four beauty industry powerhouses - Pat McGrath Labs, Bobbi Brown, MAC Cosmetics, and Charlotte Tilbury - to uncover some of the strategic WHY's that actually moved the needle in 2024.

Pat McGrath Labs: The Fashion-First Approach

With 6M Instagram followers and a strong TikTok presence, Pat McGrath Labs shows us how luxury beauty can thrive in social commerce:

• Deep integration with fashion week and runway culture
• Strategic use of fashion influencers and models
• Professional makeup artists creating elevated content
• Focus on artistry and high-fashion aesthetics

How does Pat McGrath position the brand?
Pat McGrath positions her brand with a strong connection to the fashion world. This is reflected across her channels, where she showcases runway looks she works on, highlights models as her muses, and frequently features fashion influencers and celebrities.

What is their influencer/talent approach?
Her influencer strategy ties celebrities and fashion influencers to the fashion and events culture, makeup artists to emphasize artistry, and beauty influencers to showcase products.This creates a well-rounded approach that speaks to both the artistry and the products.

How do they create community?
Pat McGrath fosters community by frequently engaging with her partners, including models, fashion brands, and celebrities. She maintains close relationships with key figures in the fashion world, reinforcing her connection to both fashion and artistry.

What is unique about their approach to content and influencers?
The brand’s unique approach lies inits seamless integration of fashion and artistry. By featuring models and influencers, often with Pat herself doing their makeup, the content remains elevated and professional, underscoring the brand's focus on artistry and high fashion.

Do they have an affiliate marketing program?
It appears the brand does not have an affiliate program in place.

‍

Bobbi Brown: The Everyday Beauty Expert

With 4.2M Instagram followers, Bobbi Brown demonstrates the power of authenticity:

• Focus on achievable, natural looks
• Strategic use of lifestyle influencers
• Market-specific celebrity partnerships
• Content emphasizing simplicity

How does the brand position itself?
The brand positions itself as the go-to for achieving a natural, everyday look, focusing on simplicity and versatility for daily moments.

What is their influencer/talent approach?
They strategically collaborate with celebrities to target specific markets (e.g., India), beauty influencers to promote products, and lifestyle influencers to expand beyond the beauty community. Their makeup artists, while not widely followed, serve primarily as content creators rather than influencers.

How do they create community?
There doesn’t appear to be a dedicated community management strategy outside of their own channels, indicating a lack of focus in this area.

What is unique about their approach to content and influencers?
Unlike brands like MAC and PatMcGrath, they also collaborate with lifestyle influencers, tapping into audiences that may not follow traditional beauty influencers or makeup artists.This highlights their focus on natural beauty for everyday moments, broadening their appeal.

Do they have an affiliate marketing program?
It appears they do, though it is not prominently featured on their website.

‍

MAC Cosmetics: The Culture-First Strategy

‍MAC Cosmetics's impressive 24.2M Instagram following comes from:

• Partnerships with Gen Z talent like Tube Girl
• Strong focus on trend-driven content
• Professional makeup artist collaborations
• Balance of trends and professional techniques

How does the brand position itself?
MAC positions itself with in trend-driven, occasion-based beauty, with a strong focus on Gen Z and social media culture.

What is their influencer/talent approach?
They collaborate with a mix of social-first influencers and more traditional beauty talent, covering a broad spectrum of influencer types.

How do they create community?
While MAC doesn't seem to have a specific community management strategy, their partnerships with talent likeTube Girl and Gabriette keep them active within key social media communities.

What is unique about their approach to content and influencers?
MAC has intensified its focus on influencer marketing, especially targeting Gen Z while boosting professional credibility. Their content is centered around social media and beauty trends, aiming for relevance and talkability in the digital space.

Do they have an affiliate marketing program?
It appears they do, but it’s not prominently featured on their website.

‍

Charlotte Tilbury: The Empowerment-Led Strategy

Boasting 6.9M Instagram followers and 1.7M TikTok followers, Charlotte Tilbury stands out through:

• Family-centered content
• Cross-industry partnerships (including gaming and Formula 1)
• Strong affiliate program
• Consistent empowerment messaging

How does the brand position itself?
Charlotte Tilbury positions itself as a glamour brand, focused on empowering individuals to feel like the most beautiful version of themselves.

What is their influencer/talent approach?
Charlotte Tilbury collaborates with a wide range of talent, from beauty and fashion influencers to makeup artists.Notably, the brand extends beyond the beauty industry by partnering with talent in areas like racing and gaming, expanding its reach and reinforcing its message of female empowerment.

How do they create community?
Charlotte Tilbury actively engages with the influencers they collaborate with by frequently commenting on their social media pages, maintaining visibility and connection.

What is unique about their approach to content and influencers?
The brand’s approach is unique inits broad reach, working with both beauty insiders and talent from other industries. They also emphasize credibility by featuring their own family and makeup artists in their content.

Do they have an affiliate marketing program?
Yes, Charlotte Tilbury supports content creators, including gamers, through an affiliate program that is prominently featured on their website.Affiliate& Ambassador Programmes.

‍

Key Takeaways for Beauty Brands

1. Authenticity Drives Sales: Successful brands align influencer partnerships with their core values
2. Platform Optimization Matters: Content strategy must be tailored to each platform's unique environment
3. Cross-Category Collaboration Works: Look beyond traditional beauty influencers
4. Community Beats Campaign: Long-term partnerships outperform one-off collaborations

[Learn how to turn your influencer marketing budget into direct sales with Comet's Ecommerce Microstores]

Looking Ahead

The beauty industry's approach to social commerce continues to evolve. The most successful brands are those that can translate social engagement into direct sales while maintaining authentic connections with their audience.

Whether you're managing an established beauty brand or building a new one, the key is to stop thinking about influencer marketing as just a reach play. Instead, focus on creating a seamless path from discovery to purchase, making every social interaction a potential point of sale.

Want to learn more about how to optimize your beauty brand's social commerce strategy? Contact us at Comet to discover how we can help transform your social media presence into a powerful sales channel.

‍

‍